Historic value needs to be preserved

Editor,

When the Lake County Commissioners consider the proposed redevelopment plan for the Kootenai Lodge, they will be shaping the future — for better or worse — of one of the most significant historic places in northwest Montana. The Mountains/Plains Office of the National Trust for Historic Preservation urges the Commissioners to protect this important landmark so that future generations can continue to experience it and be inspired by it.

The Kootenai Lodge complex illustrates an important chapter in America's story. Kirkland Cutter, architect of the famed Lake McDonald Lodge in Glacier National Park, designed the Kootenai Lodge as a retreat for businessmen and their families. In 1984, in recognition of its remarkable rustic-style architecture as well as its important place in the history of local recreation and commerce, the complex was listed in the National Register of Historic Places — one of only two listed sites in Lake County. In 1999 the National Trust, in partnership with HGTV, featured the Kootenai Lodge and the current owners' restoration efforts in an episode of the popular "Restore America" series.

Sadly, the proposed redevelopment plan — which calls for demolishing several significant elements of the complex, adding 57 new structures, and obliterating open spaces and vistas — will diminish or destroy much of the unique character that makes Kootenai Lodge such a special place. The history and beauty that draw visitors back year after year, from the Charlie Russell sketches in the main lodge courtyard to the original furnishings and stunning open vistas, are certain to be decimated.

There is room for redevelopment at Kootenai Lodge, but not at the expense of the natural and architectural features that have endeared the place to generations of visitors. The existing buildings are structurally sound and in good condition; they need not, and should not, be sacrificed. And the density of new development can and should be reduced so that historic buildings, views and open space are preserved, not spoiled.

Sarah Hansen

Program Officer

Mountains/Plains Office

National Trust for Historic Preservation

Denver